A Pragmatic Theory of Fallacy (Studies in Rhetoric and by Douglas Walton

By Douglas Walton

Even if fallacies were universal seeing that Aristotle,
till lately little consciousness has been dedicated to picking and defining
them. in addition, the idea that of fallacy itself has lacked a sufficiently
transparent aspiring to make it a great tool for comparing arguments. Douglas
Walton takes a brand new analytical examine the concept that of fallacy and presents
an up to date research of its usefulness for argumentation experiences. Walton
makes use of case stories illustrating usual arguments and tough deceptions
in daily dialog the place the cost of fallaciousness is at issue.
the various case stories express in concrete phrases many useful aspects
of the way to take advantage of textual facts to spot and examine fallacies and to
assessment arguments as mistaken. Walton seems to be at how a controversy is used
within the context of dialog. He defines a fallacy as a conversational
flow, or series of strikes, that's presupposed to be an issue that contributes
to the aim of the dialog yet actually interferes with it. The
view is a realistic one, in line with the idea that after humans argue,
they achieve this in a context of debate, a conventionalized normative framework
that's goal-directed. this kind of contextual framework is proven to be crucial
in deciding on no matter if a controversy has been used accurately. Walton also
exhibits how examples of fallacies given within the common sense textbooks characteristically
grow to be editions of moderate, no matter if defeasible or questionable
arguments, in response to presumptive reasoning. this can be the essence of the evaluation
challenge. A key thesis of the publication, which must never be taken for granted
as past textbooks have so frequently performed, is so that you can spot a fallacy
from the way it used to be utilized in a context of debate. this can be an cutting edge and
even, as Walton notes, "a radical and controversial" theory
of fallacy.

Show description

Read Online or Download A Pragmatic Theory of Fallacy (Studies in Rhetoric and Communication) PDF

Best rhetoric books

The Future of Invention: Rhetoric, Postmodernism, and the Problem of Change

Smaller, unmarried web page, retail caliber model of a prior upload

Examines the idea that of rhetorical invention from an affirmative, nondialectical perspective.

From the again Cover

The way forward for Invention hyperlinks classical rhetorical practices of invention with the philosophical paintings of Gilles Deleuze and Jacques Derrida and proposes that the most the most important implications of postmodern thought have long gone mostly unattended. Drawing on such classical rhetorical suggestions as doxa, imitation, kairos, and topos, and interesting key works via Aristotle, Plato, the Sophists, and others, John Muckelbauer demonstrates how rhetorical invention can provide a nondialectical, "affirmative" experience of swap that invitations us to reconsider the ways that we learn, write, and reply to others.

"This could be the main attention-grabbing and leading edge (inventive) publication on rhetorical invention I've encountered considering that Deleuze's what's Philosophy? Muckelbauer not just contributes to but in addition essentially alters the dialog in this subject. He manages anything that's nearly nonexistent within the field--to learn (to stick with textual strains, openings, prospects) instead of just to interpret. so much reports in rhetorical invention, beforehand, were mired in a bunch of humanist presumptions concerning the thinking/inventing subject--this paintings bargains a significant problem to that process, now not by means of arguing with it yet via appearing anything very assorted. " -- Diane Davis, writer of breaking apart [at] Totality: A Rhetoric of Laughter

"This booklet includes a wealth of artistic methods to big matters in either postmodern thought and the sector of rhetorical stories. Muckelbauer argues for and provides an unique form of engagement with those concerns that transforms scholarly discourse on invention. " -- Bradford Vivian, writer of Being Made unusual: Rhetoric past Representation

About the Author

John Muckelbauer is Assistant Professor of English on the collage of South Carolina.

Writing in Foreign Language Contexts: Learning, Teaching, and Research (Second Language Acquisition)

This booklet represents the main accomplished account up to now of overseas language writing. Its easy goal is to mirror seriously on the place the sector is now and the place it must cross subsequent within the exploration of international language writing on the degrees of idea, study, and pedagogy.

Many Sides: A Protagorean Approach to the Theory, Practice and Pedagogy of Argument

Many facets is the 1st full-length learn of Protagorean antilogic, an argumentative perform with deep roots in rhetorical background and renewed relevance for modern tradition. based at the philosophical relativism of Protagoras, antilogic is a dynamic instead of a proper method of argument, centred largely at the dialogical interplay of opposing positions (anti-logoi) in controversy.

Strategic Maneuvering in Argumentative Discourse: Extending the pragma-dialectical theory of argumentation

In Strategic Maneuvering in Argumentative Discourse, Frans H. van Eemeren brings jointly the dialectical and the rhetorical dimensions of argumentation by means of introducing the idea that of strategic maneuvering. Strategic maneuvering refers back to the arguer’s continuous efforts to reconcile aiming for effectiveness with being average.

Additional resources for A Pragmatic Theory of Fallacy (Studies in Rhetoric and Communication)

Sample text

327-28. 47. ), Embodied Selves, p. 329. Shuttleworth 'SO CHILDISH AND SO DREADFULLY UN-CHILDLIKE' 39 In the last decades of the century, idiocy was returned once more to the state of animal or sub-human. The reforming zeal of moral management which had sought to rescue and educate such beings was overwhelmed by the evolutionary pessimism of post-Darwinian psychiatry. Running alongside this vision of idiocy as a reversion to the animal, there was also, however, another vision of idiocy as a manufactured article: manufactured this time by the pressures of an over-civilized world.

200. 38. Bleak House was being serialized in Household Words when Dickens contributed his article on idiocy. It ran from March 1852 to September 1853, and had reached chapters 50-53 when Dickens published 'Idiots'. ), ch. 11, p. 179; ch. 16, p. 259. Shuttleworth 'SO CHILDISH AND SO DREADFULLY UN-CHILDLIKE' 35 Prior to nineteenth-century attempts to explore the possibilities of education for deaf mutes, they were routinely classed and housed with idiots and lunatics, their lack of communicatory skills seeming to place them outside the boundaries of social normality.

With the awakening of the 'great tee-totum' to its daily whirl, reading and writing recommences and 'Jo, and the other lower animals, get on in the unintelligible mess as they can'. Jo is then identified with the blinded, goaded oxen driven, but never guided, to market who, 'plunge, red-eyed and foaming, at stone walls; and often sorely hurt the innocent, and often sorely hurt themselves. ' Animality is here transformed from a state of linguistic ignorance to a violent force which threatens both itself and others.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.86 of 5 – based on 47 votes